In short - not really. According to a study in Adelaide (published in Road and Transport Research), park and ride schemes have been found to actually increase the number of cars on the road.
Park and ride schemes provide parking (often cheap or free) at junctions with public transport enabling commuters to drive from home for part of their journey, and take public transport for the rest. This idea was meant to encourage public transport use for people who would normally drive, and ease traffic pressure on roads.
However, the study showed that "over 82% of respondents who previously used mass transit for their entire journey now travel part of the way by car". At the same time, there was little evidence of additional trip generation for the connecting public transport services. This shows that the scheme actually puts more cars on the road than it takes off - at least in areas that are in the catchment of the parking bays.
This issue aside, there are some other beefs one may have with schemes like this. Land use is one - is parking really the most efficient use of land in locations like this - particularly when the cost of the parking for the user is usually cheap if not free? Surely there are better ways to encourage PT use (greater coverage, more services, better services, more incentives for PT and disincentives for cars)? Or is park and ride simply a short term option whilst these initiatives are in the works? What do you think?
Thanks to Scott Martin for sending through the link and interesting info on this topic.
Read the study here, and a brief newspaper article based on it at InDaily here.
Popular Posts
-
click images for larger view It all ties into one of Richard M. Daley's patented 99-year privitization deals. In 2006, a consortium led ...
-
click images for larger view With all the current controversy over economic stimulus, it's easy to forget how much of the infrastructure...
-
It's hard to imagine it's already been two years since we lost Doug Garofalo , one of Chicago's most talented young architects. ...
-
click images for larger view (recommended) Early yesterday afternoon, I made a quick survey of the second annual edition of Expo Chicago , t...
-
click images for larger view It was like Richard Meier had bled all over Pioneer Court. The usually underpopulated plaza had become a sea ...
-
Last month Glen Eira was the first of Victoria's local governments to implement the new zones , and two weeks ago, transitional arrangem...
-
Get More: 2013 VMA , Artists.MTV , Music If you were watching the VMA awards this weekend, you probably saw this early trailer for the Shai...
-
Remember when we told you we were adding the last new event to the August Calendar of Chicago Architectural Events ? We lied. Tonight Pet...
-
photograph: Bob Johnson (click images for larger view) In Chicago's skyscape, the Prudential Building was once cock of the walk. Today,...